Awesome question...
Don't quote me, but, I seem to remember watching or reading somewhere that Pagoda was the oldest.
ETA: I did find an article saying the Pagoda was one of the oldest buildings at the park (this must have be the article I remember) stated that Pagoda was built sometime between 1907-1914. Also said that it has been used for a variety of services...CP Post Office and a restroom.
There are a few buildings on Frontier Trail that were moved from other parts of Ohio and reassembled when the trail was introduced in 1971. I don't recall which ones specifically, but one or two date back to the 1820s and '30s. Hair splitting perhaps as they are not original to the island but technically they would be the oldest structures.
Girl: "l want to ride that yellow one again... Twisted Wicker"
Me: "It's a roller coaster, not a broken clothes hamper."
This subject is interesting, so I did a little look on the Google. Apparently the Grist Mill dates back to 1861, the Candle Shop dates back to 1835, and a few other cabins are from the 1820/1830s. This article is from 4 years ago but was a decent read.
https://www.themeparkinsider.com/flume/201406/4097/
If I get to the park anymore this year I'll try to poke around and see if I can dig anything else up.
Also came across the site with a little bit of history about the CP Lighthouse, which is pretty cool.
-Craig
Lifetime Laps on Woodstock Express: 0
Here is another article I found that talks about some of the historic buildings inside the park:
You must be logged in to post